Sinful colours review

today i went to wonderful world for the last day of their sale. alot of their items were discounted and all i went lookind for was a matte white eyeshadow. of course they didnt have it. but after going through their stock pile of cost price item i came up these too palettes from sinful colors. these were the only two that werent broken. And priced at an immediate sale price of two for twelve dollars who wouldnt buy them. my first instinct was that they were dupes for nyx trios but every apple has it cheese yes i would buy them as they are much cheaper than nyx. ARTIC BREEZE aptly named this consists of a matte white, a mint green and moss green shadow. the white is lightly pigmented but has some staying power with a good base like amplified. the mint green has a light shimmer and is very soft and is very pigmented with a base. the moss green is a light shimmer to metallic i cant wait to do a look with it. i give this a five palm exploding heart for awesomeness. CITY GIRL this consists of a lightly and i mean lightly shimmered lavender, then irredescent liliac ansdthen a dark shimmer purple. i love the lilac because above the base and the under the light it gives a lovely glow. im not inlove with the dark purple but u can use it for a soft smokey look. i give this a three for potential. these shadows have staying power becar after three hours they are lightly smudged after lots of hand washing. i had to literally scrub it off. i guess its the base that is helping it too. but the colours never faded.